The <title> tag is certainly there. I wonder if it's because you have it above the verification code in the source? Maybe try moving it underneath, ie
I also noticed your Google Analytics tracking code is in the wrong place - it should be at the bottom of the code, immediately before the closing </body>.
<meta name="verify-v1" content="YPk8KEo0T49rDFdwZrJTZJjvQYGc18cun3ve1xzcp5I=" />
<title>jimbuddy.com - find your gym buddy with jim!</title>
I really like the Amazon integration, hadn't realised it could be integrated like that.
Hope this helps.